Bankside Yards Strategy: the risks of challenging a century of rights to light assessment
The Bankside Yards strategy offers developers a warning about rights to light: attempting to displace an established assessment method can introduce substantial complexity without securing a better outcome.
The developer’s challenge to the Waldram method, advanced through GIA’s expert evidence, failed. Against reported developer legal costs of £3.7 million and damages totalling £850,000, the case raises a serious commercial question: was an ambitious technical challenge a proportionate way to manage the dispute?

What was the Bankside Yards case about?
The proceedings concerned Arbor, an office building within the Bankside Yards development on London’s South Bank. Kevin Cooper and Stephen and Jennifer Powell, owners of neighbouring flats in Bankside Lofts, argued that the building infringed their rights to light.
They sought an injunction requiring the building to be cut back, or damages instead. In July 2025, Mr Justice Fancourt found actionable interference but declined to grant an injunction. The awards were £500,000 for the Powells and £350,000 for Mr Cooper: £850,000 before interest.
For developers, the distinction matters. Retaining a completed building can be a significant success, while the strategy used to contest liability can still fail.
Bankside Yards strategy: GIA’s challenge to the Waldram method
GIA advised on the development’s rights to light strategy. Its expert, Gordon Ingram, advocated alternatives to Waldram, particularly median daylight factor (MDF) and median daylight illuminance (MDI), calculated using Radiance software.
The judge criticised the interpretation of those results, identifying “a significant element of cherry picking of results”. He also questioned reliance on subjective readings of false-colour graphics instead of the numerical outcomes. These criticisms concerned the application and interpretation of the evidence; they were not a finding that Radiance software itself was defective.
In our view, this was a high-risk strategy. A party seeking to replace an established assessment framework must demonstrate why its alternative provides a more reliable answer to the legal question. More sophisticated modelling does not, by itself, discharge that burden.
More than a century of Waldram evidence
Waldram’s courtroom history is commonly traced to Charles Semon & Co Ltd v Bradford Corporation [1922] 2 Ch 737. Percy Waldram’s quantitative evidence helped establish an approach that subsequently became central to rights to light practice.
That history does not make the method immune from scrutiny. Nor does any numerical assessment replace the court’s judgment about whether sufficient light remains for ordinary use and enjoyment.
Nevertheless, challenging a method with more than 100 years of judicial use creates a substantial evidential task. The practical question for a developer is whether that challenge is likely to resolve its immediate dispute efficiently.
At Bankside Yards, the court declined to replace Waldram. It recognised that newer methods could assist in marginal or unusual cases, while rejecting the proposition that they should now supplant the established approach.
Bankside Yards strategy and the reported £3.7 million costs
Press coverage reported that the developer sought recovery of £3.7 million in legal costs. That was a reported costs claim, rather than an order requiring the neighbours to pay that sum.
The subsequent costs judgment provides a firmer basis for examining where resources were spent. Fancourt J found that infringement had been contested expansively, occupied much of the trial and accounted for a very significant proportion of preparation and trial costs. The Powells were awarded two-thirds of their costs; Mr Cooper received one-third.
The unsuccessful technical challenge therefore deserves close commercial scrutiny. It required the parties and court to address competing assessment methods, adding complexity to the infringement dispute without defeating liability.
However, the court did not attribute the whole reported £3.7 million to GIA’s approach or quantify the additional expenditure caused by the methodology arguments. The litigation also involved injunctions, valuation, settlement offers and other legal issues. Attributing the entire bill to one adviser’s strategy would go beyond the findings.
What can developers learn from the Bankside Yards strategy?
Our assessment is that GIA’s attempt to displace Waldram exposed the developer to considerable evidential and commercial risk. It widened the technical dispute, attracted judicial criticism and failed to establish the proposed alternative as the appropriate replacement.
Developers should expect advisers to explain both the potential benefit of challenging established practice and the financial consequences if that challenge fails. Technical innovation needs a clear purpose, reliable interpretation and a realistic assessment of litigation risk.
At Anstey Horne, our approach is to connect technical assessment with practical development advice: identifying exposure early, explaining uncertainty and supporting informed decisions about design, negotiation and dispute resolution.
Contact our rights to light team to discuss the risks affecting your development.


